Saturday, February 11, 2012

gunpowder and lead

Holy shit, this Tommy Jordan thing. I watched part of the video yesterday at work; I never got to finish it, because, well, I was at work and had to go do something else. The link I saw, though, had been updated with a link to his Facebook page and his response. I still didn't see what all the fuss was about. Because I'd missed the crucial bit, the gun part.

You know what? Up until the gun bit? I don't have any problem with how he handled it. I couldn't understand the fuss, because the dude did not go off in the heat of the moment, exactly like parents are supposed to. He sat down, thought about it, wrote a letter that I agreed with (that "cleaning lady" shit was obnoxious, just as one example), and responded in kind. His mistake, of course, was not using a different setting on YouTube, and also thinking that Facebook was more private than it is. (Oh, and again, the gun thing.) Just like his kid, heh. And, along those lines, I frankly don't see a Facebook account as being the same as a diary, and if anyone out there is screaming about the daughter's lack of privacy on Facebook but also went around self-righteously scolding people about how "the internet is public", they need to check themselves. I also liked his initial follow-up, and actually think it was a good idea; no response at all would have still brought out the HE OWES US ANSWERSSSSSSS crowd. On the other hand, he probably needs to drop it now and keep going about his business instead of continually telling everyone that he is going about his business. On the other other hand, if people are so annoyed, why do they keep reading about it? They need to stop giving him the attention.

It's possible that I have a lot of sympathy because I have a daughter who's reaching that age herself, and hoo boy, the "discussions" we are having about entitlement boggle the mind. I don't post a whole lot about them, because posting about your kids when they are assholes is a bit different than when they are adorably mangling vocabulary. Also, because The Great Mothering Judgment Machine begins to grind away, and I am half tired of people with small kids and people without kids giving me their theoretical experiences. (Do not even get me started on the "Buy a Mac" contingent of the parenting world, who seem to think their main job is popping up on any parenting discussion with "THIS IS WHY I DON'T HAVE KIDS BLAH BLAH OPPRESSION POOP BREEDERS", but that is a different discussion.) (Additionally, I am not saying that people with no kids give terrible parenting advice. I am just annoyed that people do it even without being asked. Though, again, that's a different discussion, and one I might even feel like wading into one day.)

People are going to parent differently than you will, and that is okay. Those kids will turn out fine. Some won't. Some of that will be because of parenting. Some of it will not. Just as you can't always blame the bad things your kids do on your parenting, you also can't claim that every great thing they do is because of you, either. People parent effectively when they own guns, and when they do not. They parent effectively in all fifty states. They parent effectively no matter who they vote for. And sometimes, they do not. And what we bring to the table, from our own backgrounds, from our own parents, and what they did and what they did not do, always colors our own opinions and experiences. Which is what makes us all so different. And maybe not all right or all wrong.

But to place all the blame on parents because they're southern gun-owners who might have a different idea on what works for their own kid means we're no better than the people who think those of us more moderate/blue-state residing/atheists/whatever are raising our children poorly. Some of us are. Some of us are not. Same as everywhere else. There's no one magical answer that will work for people everywhere. We're all doing the best we can with what we have. And up until the actual shooting, he was handling it better than I would have. My neighbors would have heard me up and down the street screaming about how chores don't make you oppressed.

I have no defense for the shooting, though. That was just dumb and over the top.

For once I don't see anyone blaming the mother. I guess that's progress.

This is sort of rambly, isn't it? I guess to sum up: I am a parent. I am pro-gun. I sympathize with the dad...up until the gun bit. I don't think this makes him a terrible parent, just one who made a mistake. All parents make mistakes. And people on both sides of this issue are projecting so hard they can be seen from space.

No comments: